Three Roads to Freedom: Douglass, Washington, and Du Bois

Lesson 1

Slavery in America: the facts

Slavery in America was a system in which human beings were treated by law as property. An enslaved person could be bought, sold, rented out, and punished at an owner's will, and children born to an enslaved mother were enslaved for life. Frederick Douglass, born in Maryland around 1818, never knew his birthday, because enslaved children were kept from such knowledge. He was separated from his mother in infancy and saw her only a handful of times before she died.

The work was forced and unpaid: long days in fields and houses, plain food, thin clothing, and shelter in cabins. Families could be split apart by sale at any time, and Douglass's Narrative opens with the whipping of his Aunt Hester, a scene he witnessed as a small child. Douglass also corrects a common myth about singing on plantations. He writes, "Slaves sing most when they are most unhappy," explaining that the songs carried sorrow, not contentment. By 1860 nearly four million people were enslaved in the United States, and the system lasted until the Thirteenth Amendment ended it in 1865, after the Civil War.

Lesson 2

Douglass learns to read

At about age eight Douglass was sent to Baltimore to live with Hugh and Sophia Auld. Sophia, who had never owned a slave before, kindly began teaching him the alphabet and short words. Then her husband found out and forbade it, saying that teaching a slave to read was unlawful and unsafe, and that learning would make him unfit to be a slave. Douglass, listening, understood the lesson hidden inside the warning.

He writes, "I understood the pathway from slavery to freedom." If reading would unfit a man for slavery, then reading must be the road out of it. So the boy became his own teacher. He befriended hungry white boys in the street and traded bread for reading lessons, telling them he was learning a word he could not spell. He copied letters from shipyard timber, traced the handwriting in his young master's copy books, and practiced in secret for years. Reading opened newspapers, the Bible, and a famous book of speeches called The Columbian Orator, which gave him arguments against slavery and words for his own thoughts.

Lesson 3

Douglass fights back and escapes

At sixteen Douglass was sent to Edward Covey, a poor farmer with a reputation for breaking young slaves. For six months Covey worked him nearly past endurance in all weather, and Douglass writes that he was broken in body, soul, and spirit. Then, in August 1833, after collapsing in the heat and being beaten again, Douglass fought back. He seized Covey and wrestled with him for nearly two hours until Covey gave up. Covey never whipped him again, and Douglass calls the turning point the moment a slave was made a man.

Five years later, in September 1838, Douglass escaped from Baltimore. He traveled by train and boat to New York City, helped by Anna Murray, a free Black woman who later became his wife, and by abolitionist David Ruggles once he arrived. In his Narrative Douglass deliberately refuses to describe exactly how he escaped, so that no slaveholder could use his book to block the road for others still fleeing. He settled in New Bedford, Massachusetts, worked as a laborer, and soon began speaking publicly against slavery, the first step toward becoming its most famous witness.

Lesson 4

Washington builds Tuskegee

Booker T. Washington was born enslaved in Virginia in 1856 and freed as a boy when the Civil War ended slavery. He worked in salt furnaces and a coal mine in West Virginia, taught himself from a spelling book, and walked and worked his way to Hampton Institute, where he studied under General Samuel Armstrong. In 1881 Alabama officials asked Hampton for a teacher to start a normal school for Black students at Tuskegee, and Armstrong sent Washington.

He arrived in June 1881 to find no building, no land, and very little money. The school opened on July 4, 1881, in a dilapidated shanty and a small church, with about thirty students. Washington and his students set out to build the school themselves. They cleared land, dug clay, and after many failed attempts learned to make good bricks, bricks so good that local builders of both races came to buy them. Students raised crops, built Porter Hall, the first large building, and literally constructed their own education. Aided by his wife Olivia Davidson, who raised money in the North, Washington turned the shanty school into Tuskegee Institute, a campus built largely by student labor.

Lesson 5

Work, thrift, and self-help

Washington's teaching can be summed up in one of his own sayings: "Cast down your bucket where you are." In his famous Atlanta Exposition address of 1895 he told the story of a thirsty ship that lowered its bucket beside the mouth of the Amazon River and drew up fresh water. His point was practical. Begin with what is at hand: the farm, the trade, the home ground, and the neighbors you already have.

From that starting point his program followed. Learn a useful skill and do common work so well that it becomes dignified. He taught that there is as much dignity in tilling a field as in writing a poem. Save money, buy land, own a home, and build habits of thrift, cleanliness, and reliability. At Tuskegee this meant training teachers, farmers, carpenters, brick masons, and homemakers, and sending graduates out to lift whole communities. Washington also judged success in an unusual way, not by the position a person reaches, but by the obstacles that person has overcome to get there. Critics, as the next lessons show, thought this program asked for patience at the price of rights, but nobody doubted the energy and discipline behind it.

Lesson 6

Du Bois and double consciousness

W. E. B. Du Bois was born free in Massachusetts in 1868, three years after slavery ended. He studied at Fisk University in Nashville, then earned a doctorate at Harvard in 1895, the first African American to do so. In The Souls of Black Folk, published in 1903, he gives his most famous idea a name: double consciousness.

Du Bois describes it as the feeling of always looking at yourself through the eyes of others, of measuring your worth by the standards of a world that may look back with contempt or pity. A Black American, he writes, feels a twoness: an American and a Negro, two souls and two strivings inside one body. His wish was not to erase either self, but to make it possible to be both without being cursed or shut out of opportunity. He also pictures a veil between Black Americans and the rest of the country, a thin barrier of race and misunderstanding that separates two worlds living side by side. The book mixes history, essays, short fiction, and the sorrow songs of slavery, which Du Bois calls the most beautiful expression of human experience born on American soil.

Lesson 7

The great debate: Washington versus Du Bois

By 1903 Washington was the most influential Black leader in America, and Du Bois devoted a chapter of The Souls of Black Folk to a respectful but firm answer. He praised Washington's sincerity, tact, and institution building, then named three things he believed the Atlanta Compromise had given up too easily: political power, insistence on civil rights, and the higher education of Black youth.

Du Bois argued the case step by step. Without the vote, a people cannot protect its schools, homes, or earnings in a democracy. Without civil equality, working men are trained for a world that still bars the door. And a race needs its college trained leaders, its teachers, thinkers, and doctors, as much as its craftsmen; Du Bois later called that leadership group the talented tenth. Washington answered that in the hostile South of the 1890s, demanding everything at once could destroy the chance to build anything at all, and that economic strength would in time win respect and rights. Both men wanted the same destination, a free and prosperous people. They disagreed, deeply and in public, about which road would get there first, and their argument shaped Black American politics for decades.

Lesson 8

What each road teaches us now

Read together, the three lives form one larger lesson. From Douglass we learn that the mind is the first ground of freedom. A boy forbidden to read made reading his rescue, then used his pen and voice to help free millions, which is why literacy campaigns and open libraries still carry his spirit. From Washington we learn the dignity and power of building: skills, savings, land, and institutions raised by a community's own hands. Tuskegee still stands, and its model of learning by doing lives on in trade schools and maker spaces everywhere.

From Du Bois we learn that skills and property are not the whole of freedom. A person also needs the vote, equal standing before the law, and the full education of his or her talents, and somebody must be willing to say so clearly and in print. Du Bois helped found the NAACP in 1909 and edited its magazine, The Crisis, for decades. The honest ending is that each road corrects the others. Work without rights is fragile, rights without economic strength are shaky, and neither matters if people are kept from books. Freedom, these three argue across a century, needs all three roads at once.

Sources

The Books Behind This Course

This course is taught from classic texts that are free for anyone to read. Every method in the lessons traces back to one of these books.

• Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave by Frederick Douglass (1845), Project Gutenberg
• Up from Slavery by Booker T. Washington (1901), Project Gutenberg
• The Souls of Black Folk by W. E. B. Du Bois (1903), Project Gutenberg

Graduation

Three roads, one destination

Douglass reached for a book, Washington reached for a brick, and Du Bois reached for the ballot and the university, but all three were walking toward the same city: a life of full freedom and dignity. You now know their stories in their own words, where they agreed, and where they argued. Whichever road your own life takes, you will walk it better for having studied the maps these three men drew at such cost.

Back to Starvard University